Mediate, Negotiate, Collaborate

Who Gets the Dog in Divorce?

June 15, 2024
Who Gets the Dog in Divorce?

Divorce is a challenging process that involves many difficult decisions, especially when it comes to beloved pets. Many couples' pets are more than just animals; they are cherished family members. Determining who gets the dog in a divorce can be a highly emotional and contentious issue. Understanding how pet custody is handled in New York can help you navigate this complex situation.

What Constitutes Divorce in NY?

Divorce in New York involves the legal dissolution of a marriage through specific grounds, processes, and requirements. Here's a concise overview:

Grounds for Divorce:

  • No-Fault: Irretrievable breakdown of the marriage for at least six months.
  • Fault-Based: Adultery, cruel and inhuman treatment, abandonment for one year, imprisonment for three or more consecutive years, and living apart for one year under a separation agreement or court order.

Filing Requirements:

  • Residency: One spouse must meet residency requirements (e.g., lived in NY for at least two years, married in NY, or lived as spouses in NY for at least one year).


  • Filing: One spouse files a summons and complaint, and the other spouse is served.
  • Equitable Distribution: Marital property is divided fairly, though not necessarily equally.
  • Child Custody and Support: Decisions are based on the child's best interests.
  • Spousal Support (Alimony): May be awarded based on the length of the marriage and each spouse's financial situation.
  • Settlement Agreements: Couples can negotiate terms outside of court, which are then approved by the court.
  • Final Judgment: The court issues a final judgment of divorce, officially ending the marriage.

Pets as Property in New York

Who Gets the Dog in Divorce?

In New York, pets are legally classified as property, similar to other personal possessions such as furniture or vehicles. This classification can seem cold and impersonal to pet owners who view their pets as family members. However, the legal system must have a way to handle the division of all assets, and pets are included in this process.

Legal Framework

The New York courts follow the principle of equitable distribution during a divorce, which means that marital property is divided fairly, though not necessarily equally. Since pets are considered property, they are subject to this principle. The court can have to decide which spouse will retain ownership of the pet based on factors similar to those used for dividing other assets.

Ownership and Contribution

When determining who gets the pet, the court may look at who originally purchased or adopted the pet, who has been financially responsible for the pet's needs, and who has invested the most time and care in the pet's upbringing. Documentation such as adoption papers, veterinary records, and receipts for pet-related expenses can be pivotal in demonstrating ownership and contributions.

Best Interests of the Pet

Although pets are considered property, some courts in New York have begun to consider their best interests, much like child custody cases. This progressive approach acknowledges the special bond between pets and their owners. Judges may evaluate who can provide the best environment and care for the pet, considering factors like living arrangements, work schedules, and the presence of children.

Case Precedents

Several notable cases in New York have involved courts that have considered the emotional attachment and the pet's well-being when deciding. These cases reflect a growing trend toward recognizing pets' unique status within families.

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Given the emotional stakes in pet custody disputes, many couples prefer to settle matters outside of court. Mediation and collaborative divorce processes allow couples to reach a mutually satisfactory agreement regarding pet custody without relying solely on the court's interpretation of property laws. This often leads to more personalized and considerate arrangements that reflect the true nature of the relationship between the pet and each party.

Pet Custody and Support

While the concept of "pet custody" is not officially recognized in the same way as child custody, more divorcing couples are including pet custody and visitation agreements in their settlements. These agreements can specify who will have primary custody of the pet, how visitation will be handled, and how the pet care costs will be shared.

How Michelle Bullock Law and Mediation Can Help

At Michelle Bullock Law and Mediation, we understand your emotional attachment to your pets. Our experienced team is dedicated to guiding you through the complexities of pet custody during a divorce. Here’s how we can assist you:

  • Experienced Guidance: We provide knowledgeable advice on how New York law treats pets in divorce proceedings, helping you understand your rights and options.
  • Custody Agreements: We assist in drafting comprehensive pet custody agreements that cover all aspects of pet care, including custody arrangements, visitation schedules, and shared expenses.
  • Mediation Services: Our mediation services offer a neutral ground for both parties to discuss their needs and reach a mutually agreeable solution, focusing on your pet's best interests.
  • Personalized Support: Every situation is unique, and we tailor our approach to fit your specific circumstances, ensuring that your pet’s well-being is prioritized throughout the process.
  • Conflict Resolution: We work to minimize conflict and foster cooperation between parties, aiming for amicable resolutions that reduce stress for you and your pet.

If you are facing a divorce and need assistance with pet custody or any other aspect of the process, please contact us to schedule a consultation. We are here to help you navigate this challenging time with care and professionalism.

Contact Us Today

If you are dealing with a divorce and need guidance on pet custody or any other matters, Michelle Bullock Law and Mediation is here to help. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and ensure the best outcome for you and your beloved pet.

Who Gets the Dog in Divorce? FAQs

At Michelle Bullock Law and Mediation, we understand that determining pet custody during a divorce can be a challenging and emotional process. Here are some frequently asked questions to help you navigate this issue:

How does New York law treat pets in a divorce?

In New York, pets are legally considered property. However, courts increasingly recognize the emotional bonds between pets and their owners and may consider factors beyond ownership and financial contributions.

What factors do courts consider when deciding pet custody?

Courts may consider several factors, including:

  • Who has been the primary caregiver.
  • Each party’s living situation.
  • Financial ability to care for the pet.
  • Work schedules and availability.
  • The attachment between the pet and any children involved.
  • The overall welfare and best interests of the pet.

Can we create a pet custody agreement?

Yes, couples can create a pet custody agreement that outlines custody arrangements, visitation schedules, shared expenses, and decision-making responsibilities regarding the pet’s care.

Is mediation available for pet custody disputes?

Yes, mediation can be an effective way to resolve pet custody disputes. A neutral mediator can help both parties communicate their needs and reach a mutually agreeable solution.

What if one spouse originally purchased or adopted the pet?

While the original purchase or adoption of the pet may be a factor, courts will also consider who has been the primary caregiver and other factors that affect the pet’s well-being.

Can the court enforce a pet custody agreement?

Yes, if a pet custody agreement is included in the divorce settlement and approved by the court, it becomes legally binding and enforceable.

Contact Me To Discuss Your Options

Fields marked with an * are required

5500 Main St. 
Suite 215 
Williamsville, NY 
Amherst Location

Office Numbers:


Follow Me On:

© 2023 Michelle S. Bullock Law & Mediation PLLC • All Rights Reserved