When a marriage is struggling, couples often face the tough decision of whether to legally separate or file for divorce. While both options represent significant changes in a relationship, they are different in many ways. It’s crucial to understand these differences to make the most informed decision.
In New York, a legal separation is a written agreement (Separation Agreement) between a married couple who decide to live apart, detailing the rights and responsibilities of each spouse. While similar to a divorce in that it involves issues such as property division, child custody, and support arrangements, a legal separation does not officially end the marriage.
In New York, both separation and divorce involve a legal process, but they differ in their effects and the extent to which they dissolve a marriage.
In a legal separation, the couple remains legally married. They are not free to remarry unless they obtain a divorce.
A legal separation in New York typically involves a separation agreement and a contract between spouses that outlines their rights and responsibilities. This document covers areas like:
Legally separated couples can still enjoy some benefits of a married couple, such as certain health insurance benefits or tax benefits.
If a couple decides to reconcile after a legal separation, they can do so without having to remarry. The separation agreement can simply be revoked if both parties consent.
After living apart for one year under a valid Separation Agreement, a spouse can petition the court to convert the separation into a divorce.
A divorce legally ends a marriage. Once a divorce is finalized, both individuals are free to remarry.
Similar to a Separation Agreement, a divorce settlement agreement covers the division of marital property, child custody and visitation, and spousal and child support. However, these decisions are incorporated into a legally binding court order in a divorce.
After a divorce, ex-spouses typically lose the rights and privileges that come with marriage, including health insurance benefits or filing joint tax returns.
Unlike a separation, a divorce is final. If a divorced couple wishes to reunite, they would have to remarry.
In New York, you must have specific grounds to file for divorce, such as "irretrievable breakdown of the relationship" for at least six months, adultery, cruel and inhuman treatment, abandonment for a continuous period of one year or more, three years of consecutive imprisonment, or living apart for one year or more pursuant to a valid Separation Agreement or court judgment.
In a legal separation, you are still legally married, which might be preferable for religious, moral, or financial reasons. Divorce, however, completely dissolves the marriage.
With a legal separation, you cannot remarry, as you are still legally married to your spouse. After a divorce, however, you are free to remarry.
Reconciliation might be simpler with a legal separation. If you reconcile after a divorce, you'd need to remarry or enter into a new legal agreement.
Certain benefits like health insurance or tax benefits may continue during a legal separation, while a divorce would terminate these.
In a legal separation, you may still have rights to property ownership or inheritance. Divorce usually involves a more definitive split of property.
Financial responsibility during a separation can be a complex issue and often depends on several factors including the laws of your particular state, the terms of any separation agreement, and the specific circumstances of your marriage. Here are some general principles:
If you have a separation agreement in place, it should outline each spouse's financial responsibilities. This can include who is responsible for ongoing bills such as utilities, mortgage or rent, credit card debts, and personal loans. It can also outline how joint assets should be managed.
Depending on the specifics of your situation, one spouse may be required to pay child or spousal support during the separation. This is often the case if there is a significant disparity in income between the two spouses.
Unless otherwise specified in a separation agreement, both spouses may remain responsible for joint debts, even if they're living separately. This could include joint credit cards, mortgages, or other loans.
Generally, any debts incurred individually after the separation date will be the sole responsibility of the spouse who incurred them. However, it's important to establish the date of separation clearly, as debts incurred prior to this date may still be considered joint responsibility.
Unless you are legally divorced by the end of the tax year, you will likely need to file a joint tax return or choose the "married filing separately" status.
The decision to opt for a legal separation instead of a divorce is often based on personal, financial, or religious reasons. While both allow couples to live separately, there are some potential advantages to legal separation:
Legal separation allows for the possibility of reconciliation. If the spouses resolve their differences, they can simply resume their marriage without having to remarry.
Some couples choose legal separation for financial reasons. For instance, one spouse may be able to remain on the other's health insurance plan. Or, they may receive tax benefits from remaining legally married.
Some religions forbid or discourage divorce. In these cases, a legal separation allows a couple to live separately without violating their religious beliefs.
Some couples might feel more comfortable with a legal separation due to personal or emotional reasons. They might not be ready for the finality of a divorce.
If one spouse is accruing significant debt, the other spouse may seek a legal separation to protect themselves from potential liability.
Certain social security benefits and military spousal rights require a certain length of marriage. Remaining legally separated but married allows the couple to reach these milestones.
Some parents choose legal separation as they believe it's less disruptive for their children compared to divorce.
Choosing between legal separation and divorce is a deeply personal decision. It depends on your unique situation and what you feel is right for you and your family. Before making a decision, it's important to consult with a knowledgeable divorce mediation lawyer who can provide guidance based on your specific circumstances and local laws. The ultimate goal is to choose the path that provides the most support and peace of mind during a difficult time.
© 2023 Michelle S. Bullock Law & Mediation PLLC • All Rights Reserved